Journal Article Critique

Journal Article CritiqueIn the field of editing, it is no secret that a well-written journal article can be the first step to getting hired for a new job. Having a good written critique can be the key to making this happen, and it is very important to know how to go about getting one.A journal article critique can go a long way in establishing an editor's opinion on a piece of writing. First and foremost, it should be clear and concise. Not all writing is polished and not all writing can be easily read. The critique should give an overview of the writing style, as well as provide a positive or negative reaction.The editorial staff may make the first comment in this critical critique. However, it is also possible for the editor to offer a positive opinion on the article before writing a review. There is nothing wrong with this. The editor's perspective can often be very helpful. The important thing is to get something constructive out of the editorial response.Some editors may offer a negative response in the middle of the piece. This is fine. However, an editor that does not offer an opinion is essentially telling the writer that there is nothing wrong with their writing style. A positive response from the editorial staff can help the writer understand how to proceed.The first step in making a work through on a writing critique is to get a response. The first thing to do is write a letter or email to the editor regarding the critique. While they will most likely ask for a response after reading the piece, it is a good idea to allow them time to respond.Once you receive a response, the next step is to write up your notes about the feedback. You can begin by rewording any passages that may need a rewrite. If you cannot rewrite any sections, you may have to edit the piece. Do not despair. This does not mean that the editor did not give you constructive criticism.Once you have rewritten your material, you should provide a paragraph summary of the entire piece. Incl ude any footnotes in this outline. You should include all relevant sections as well as the editor's response. You should also add a summary paragraph at the end of the piece to wrap things up.After you have completed this, you should consider keeping the document paper and marking it up. You can then send it to the editor. If you have some additional comments to add, now is the time to do so. This small part of the process will greatly affect the final result.